
One of the more satisfying paradoxes about the first two Spider-Man movies is that, although they were about a nerdy high school student coping with superpowers, they were also two of the more adult and character-driven superhero movies to come down the pike in quite a while. Unfortunately, the last movie reverses this, being not only plot-driven with a vengeance, but also relying on a number of increasingly outré happenings to flog the story along.
***SPOILERS!!***
You’ve been warned.
While I grant that a certain amount of unlikely coincidence and occurrence is inevitable in any saga that begins with a radioactive (sorry; genetically-enhanced) spider bite, Spidey III abuses the privilege (and the audience) with plot devices worthy of Rube Goldberg. Consider: Harry Osborne decides to avenge Daddy’s death by becoming the New Goblin (a name no self-respecting supervillain would touch). Without even granting our hero the courtesy of a costume change, he pursues Peter Parker above the New York streets, until somehow (I don’t even remember how; another problem with the movie is that the action sequences are confusing as hell) New Gobby manages to whang his head real good against a pipe or on a pigeon or something and winds up with short-term (and highly-selective) amnesia, putting him in plot limbo for the duration of the movie, until it serves the filmmakers’ purposes for him to snap out of it. Which he does, only by now Peter’s succumbed to the dark side because this alien symbiote that’s just happened to crash-land its meteorite in Central Park right next to where he and MJ are watching shooting stars has turned Peter into a disco-loving, finger-shooting Tony Manero clone, who dazzles the chicks in a painfully protracted dance number that’s more out of Saturday Night Live than Saturday Night Fever. (I laughed out loud in the theater when Dr. Curt “Lizard” Conners describes the symbiote sample as something along the lines of a “chondrite from the Seventies.”) And it turns out the symbiote can play the piano as well. Who knew?
But of course our hero eventually triumphs over his baser instincts and cooler hairstyle and, with the aid of the bells of Saint Pat’s, divests himself of the black goo, which unfortunately drips all over Eddie Brock (Topher Grace), turning him into Venom. (Speaking of plot devices that would make Ed Wood blink, Eddie is there in the church because he’s come to beg the Almighty to kill Peter Parker.)
One of the film’s few saving graces (aside from Topher) is Thomas Hayden Church as the Sandman. He simply rules. Not only does he uncannily look the part, but he really makes the most of what little he’s given to work with. Unfortunately, he’s also totally unnecessary to the plot, and at the end, it’s not even him — it’s just a big blob of computerized sand. (And yes, I know Church did the mo-cap, but it’s still not the same thing.)
I could go on — I haven’t mentioned many of the other false notes struck, such as Captain Stacy (James Cromwell, also sadly underused) and Brock casually exchanging intros while Stacy’s daughter dangles screaming from a construction crane, or Harry’s complete 180 when Bernard the Butler tells him an utterly unconvincing story that’s supposed to prove that the Green Goblin was responsible for his own death, or the contrived re-opening of Uncle Ben’s murder case, or the deja vu of Mary Jane hanging from a great height for the third time in as many films … but I think you get the idea. (And, to be fair, MJ wasn’t hung out over the abyss in II so much as being sucked into Doc Ock’s fusion ball by some kind of mysterious force that only seemed to attract iron and redheads.)
But the point, I trust, is made. While it contains many excellent moments, and while I can’t praise Church’s Sandman portrayal highly enough, Spider-Man III is essentially a long and massively-contrived buildup to a third act that’s nothing more than an overblown CGI homage to Marvel Team-Up. It’s not an auspicious start to the summer blockbusters.
Sigh … Maybe FF2: Rise Of the Silver Surfer will be better …